Last night I was at my local supermarket and, on a whim, decided to have frozen pizza for dinner. Looking for something different, I went for the Cape Cod Café Pepperoni Pizza which, according to the label, is made by the founder’s grandsons who “carry on the tradition of hard work and the mentality of never cutting corners to make sure the pizzas today are the same as Papa made them over 80 years ago.”
I cooked the pie according to the package directions and it was just awful. Unpleasant to eat, unpleasant again when it haunted me in the middle of the night. And it made me realize how unsatisfactory frozen pizzas are in general because of a Hobbesian choice: the producer can use a prebaked crust, in which the pie is dry and cracker-y, or a “rising crust” which bakes in the oven and is doughy and bready. In both cases the crust insults and overwhelms the toppings.
Have I ever had a frozen pizza I would eat again? Vicolo’s is a brand with a thick cornmeal crust you can buy on the west coast. In this case the crust becomes a benefit, but the frozen pizza can’t hold a candle to the fresh pies that were sold in Vicolo’s now-closed restaurant. Actually, turns out we did a frozen pizza taste test back in 2017 in which we tried 3 different brands and found them all woeful. If anyone has a frozen pizza they would recommend, I would like to hear about it!

This picture is from the Cape Cod Cafe website and also appears on the Goldbelly page. Now that looks like something I might eat…
Getting back to Cape Cod pizza, the claim that my frozen hockey puck was made the same as 80 years ago is probably not true; a third party processing plant is likely involved though it is not identified on the package. Goldbelly will ship you 4 actual pies from the pizza shop for $99; they look quite different on the website from my supermarket product.
And according to a Google search result“[Cape Cod style is] a specific kind of pizza — a 10-inch pie with a flaky, buttery crust that has sauce and cheese to the edges. They’re usually topped with a combination of mozzarella and cheddar cheese and can have “laced” — or burnt — edges.” Sounds interesting. If I get to Cape Cod I just might try one.













