Our local high school held a very successful fundraiser this week called PIZZA WARS! Six non-chain local pizza places were invited to submit their slices for tasting and judging in the categories of Best Topping, Best Crust and Best Overall. The competing businesses were Pizza Etc, Pope’s Pizza, Caputo’s Pizzeria, West Avenue Pizza, Rustic Pizza and Eats, D’Andrea’s, and 9 Miles East. Saratoga Springs is a pizza-loving town and all of these were familiar to me except the first which is actually from the town next door to us in Ballston Spa.
Tasting tickets were $6.19 in advance (including service charge) or $7 at the door, a bargain any way you look at it, and presumably the pizzas were donated and the labor was school volunteers so receipts went 100% to the Saratoga Schools Education Foundation, the official sponsor. They said the event was “sold out” and attendance was easily in the hundreds so this is an idea worth copying.

West Ave, the Pizza Wars winner, is stationed at lower right in this crowd photo. The kid with the green shirt has the sole job of stamping tickets so the others don’t have to take their sanitary gloves to do it: typical attention to detail from this establishment.
Burnt My Fingers was there to stuff our pie hole, of course, but also to enjoy the strategizing the pizza places used to put a thumb on the scale appeal to voters. A couple (including Pizza Etc, whose bold choice for serving was a sauceless veggie), served up small, sensible bites which probably took them out of the running. Others offered full slices and some also had a choice of toppings to choose from. You had to choose one only from each tasting station, and they stamped a booklet to prevent double dipping.
Our favorite, and predicted winner, was West Avenue Pizza, offering a generous square with a topping of beautifully cupped pepperoni. This is an outfit run by an entrepreneurial family of Guatemalan immigrants who also own an excellent chicken place next door. They achieved notoriety when pizza savant Dave Portnoy rated them high in his one-bite tasting tour, and they are a fixture at various local public events. The quality of their products and attention to detail is consistently high.
Results: West Avenue Pizza did indeed take Best Pizza and also Best Crust. Best Topping, however, went to Pope’s which had a not-so-secret ingredient in its sauce: sugar. We left stuffed and happy with the experience.













