You want to make a Chicago-style hot dog in your non-Chicago kitchen but you lack the essential poppy seed bun. What to do? You could order S. Rosen buns from Vienna Beef at a somewhat elevated price, or you could try our entirely acceptable poppyseed hot dog bun hack. We borrowed it from this King Arthur Poppy Seed Bun recipe, which produces a delicious product that is more like a breadstick than a puffy compliant hot dog bun.
Start with a pack of grocery store hot dog buns. Potato buns are tempting, but store brand buns are so cheap and will get the job done. Separate an egg white from the yolk and mix with equal amount of water. Brush generously onto tops of buns (one egg white + water is enough for 16 buns, easily) then sprinkle on poppy seeds to your preference. Bake in a 300 degree oven for 10 minutes to set the seeds and you’re done.
José Andres, in his Wirecutter hot dog critique, disparaged poppy seed buns because he thought the seeds belong in the dough, not on the crust. We emphatically disagree. The occasional crunch as you bite into a poppy seed is yet another layer of a complex experience, as is the tactile feel of the seeds on your hands as you are loading the dog into your pie hole. As Jeff Probst says on Survivor, “worth it!”
By the way, we baked our poppyseed hot dog buns using the unseparated layers of buns as they come out of the package. A bonus of this setup is that you will waste fewer poppy seeds because they can’t spill between the buns. But the buns will be too soft to eat when they come out of the oven and you need to let them cool off/dry out a bit before using. Or separate the buns before seeding and heating.














