Taste test: ketchup

Ketchup Taste Test

Ketchup taste test: Heinz vs house brand.

Currently on Burnt My Fingers, three of our top five posts are taste tests in which a panel (of one or more, sometimes much more) samples multiple brands of a product and reports on the results. Our ketchup taste test doesn’t end up in those readership numbers because it happened when we had far fewer readers than today. But it’s valid now as it was then, so take a look.

Heinz Ketchup seems to be an iconic brand that people will pay extra for, even though house brands can be had for far less. But how much better is Heinz Ketchup than our local supermarket’s product? When you think about ketchup you are looking for the right sweet/sour balance combined with a recognizable tomato taste, correct?

To our surprise the house brand product equaled the national brand in taste, color and texture while adding an interesting peppery note that Heinz lacked. The ketchup taste test winner in a blind tasting: Price Chopper house brand! Check it out.

PS. As a result of some rather fuzzy rebranding, the Price Chopper products are now called PICs.

 

 

This entry was posted in Eating and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Taste test: ketchup

  1. Chuckeye Dave says:

    PICs? At least you know what Price Chopper was thinking. How’s Market 32 doing?
    A new brand: Crav’n. For the coward in us all…

    • Burnt My Fingers says:

      We have a Korean taco place in Saratoga called Kraverie. Crav’n is better. I’d try it though would wear a mask when I purchase.

      As you know we are Wegmans-less in the Capital district so our choices for a mass market supermarket are Market 32/Price Chopper vs Hannafords. I live closer to a Hannaford now and have found their prices are generally better and the quality is equivalent though only PC has CAB meat. I still don’t know why Price Chopper changed its name to Market 32 and I doubt they do either.

  2. Chuckeye Dave says:

    CAB is Pchops for me. Frozen seafood too. Check out PriceRite in Schenectady. The 3 P’s: produce, pork shoulder, fresh (plastic wrapped…) Porgies! Inexpensive other stuff too, varies, Hispanic, Asian, Italian, ‘merican. Hannafords coming soonish. We have PChops half brother Tops, ehhh. My beef against Wegmans is the beef.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.