Recipe: Election Cake

Election Cake

Election Cake with a dollop of sweetened whipped cream

U.S. Election Day in the early years of our Republic was a happy and festive occasion. Election Cake was served as a reward for voting or simply to celebrate democracy. A number of bakers are offering it this year to encourage people to vote in our less jovial era, as part of the “Make America Cake Again” initiative. Election Cake rises with sourdough or yeast, not baking powder (which hadn’t been invented yet) and features spices which were popular around 1800. Adapted by Susannah Gebhart for OWL Bakery from Richard Miscovich’s formula*, and further modified by me. Makes 2 small or 1 large cake.

Ingredients—for the preferment:
280 g whole milk
75 g active sourdough starter @ 100% hydration
280 g all purpose flour or high extraction flour

320 g whole milk
¼ t instant yeast
320 g all purpose flour or high extraction flour

Ingredients—for the cake:
1 c unsalted butter (226 g)
1/3 c unrefined sugar or 50/50 mix of brown and white sugar (155 g)
2 eggs (100 g)
1/3 c whole-milk yogurt (85 g)
¼ c blackstrap molasses/sorghum/honey (60 g)
Preferment (640-645 g)
280 g high extraction flour OR 140 d all purpose flour and 140 g whole wheat flour
1 ½ t ground cinnamon
1 ½ t ground coriander
¼ t ground allspice
¼ t freshly grated nutmeg
¼ t ground black pepper
¼ t ground coriander (1 g)
¼ t ground black pepper (1 g)
2 t salt (12 g)
2 T brandy (optional)
Up to 1 c dried fruit (optional; if very dry, reconstitute with water in the microwave)

Method: DAY 1: Combine whole milk and starter or yeast. Add flour and mix thoroughly. Cover and proof overnight or until light and bubbly at 70 degrees.

DAY 2: Cream the butter in a stand mixer with the paddle attachment then add sugar and mix at second speed until light and fluffy. Add the eggs one at a time then the molasses/sorghum/honey and yogurt. Replace the paddle attachment with a dough hook and add preferment and mix well. Combine all dry ingredients in a bowl with flour and mix well with a spoon; add to liquid ingredients and mix at second speed for 2 minutes. Add optional fruit (I used ½ c dried cranberries and ½ c candied orange and lemon peel) and brandy and mix until just combined.

Election Cake

1 of 2 cakes baked in a double bundt pan designed for a Halloween Pumpkin cake.

Pour batter into square or round cake pan or bundt pan which has been buttered and floured. Bake at 375 degrees for 10 minutes, then reduce temperature to 350 degrees until a toothpick inserted into the cake comes out clean; for me this took about 30 minutes, for 40 minutes total baking time. Turn out onto a wire rack and cool completely before serving. You can serve as-is, but the cake is not particularly sweet so a glaze or accompanying whipped cream or ice cream is recommended.

Local note for my readers in the 518: according to a reliable source, the first recipe for Election Cake appeared in Amelia Simmons’ second edition of American Cookery, published in 1796.

*The big difference with the formula Richard Miscovich shared at the 2016 Kneading Conference is that Richard added ALL his flour to the preferment, which would give the cake an extra tang. Try that option if you like.

Posted in Baking and Baked Goods, Recipes, Sweets | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Recipe: Skillet Steak

Skillet Steak

Skillet Steak after about 1/2 has been consumed, it was that good

This is a very simple recipe that may produce the best steak you have ever had.

Cast iron skillet
Steak that is not larger than the skillet
Kosher salt
Other seasonings of your choice

Method: Heat your seasoned cast iron skillet until it is very hot. (It will start to throw off vapors.) Sprinkle a generous amount of Kosher salt inside the skillet and slap down the steak. Season the “up” side with a flavoring of your choice; I use Burger House seasoning. After a couple of minutes, flip the steak. (If you happen to have some precooked potatoes or other veggies you’d like to enjoy with the steak, toss them in now.)

Let the steak cook on its second side for a minute then turn off the heat and let it rest 10 minutes. Serve, for one of the best steaks you’ve ever enjoyed.

Posted in Mains, Recipes | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Rainier Ale discontinued? Alas, it’s true.

Rainier Ale discontinued

Rainier Ale. Discontinued. Photo courtesy of

The Green Death is dead. Rainier Ale has been discontinued. I learned this the hard way, by searching for retail sources on my last visit to San Francisco and retrieving a map that was completely blank. I emailed Pabst Brewing, which now owns the brand, and they sent back this heartbreaking response:

Otis – Thank you for taking the time to contact Pabst Brewing Company with your interest in Rainier Ale.

Regrettably, due to its poor sales performance, we have decided to discontinue Rainier Ale. We would like to thank you for your support over the years, but unfortunately sales simply were not enough to continue producing the product…

I apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused, and thank you again for contacting Pabst Brewing Company.

Inconvenience? Read the Final Rainier Ale Thread on the 40 oz Malt Liquor Paradise BBS and you’ll see it’s much more than that. These bros are crying in their beer over the demise of what the thread’s originator feels is a near perfect quaff: “The flavor is amazing, the buzz is great, the % is perfect, it has that crisp ale taste with a finish only a fresh water stream from Mt Rainier could provide.”

Okay, maybe that’s a bit much. The folks who dubbed it the “Green Death” might argue that the stream was more likely from a leaky bathroom facility, judging by the effect. When I had a bit too much in my younger years I would indeed feel a bit devastated the next day… not so much a hangover as a feeling of hopelessness, signaling either that I was about to die or that I was already dead.

But since I moved east from San Francisco I have developed a finer appreciation for Rainier Ale, which I would seek out and generally find in colorful neighborhoods on my return trips and enjoy in moderation. The product actually mutated over the years and the most recent version was akin to a good German lager: light, but with a backbone. At either 7.3% or 6.9% ABV (the percentage shifted downward toward the end) it had the strength of an IPA but the drinkability of a session beer… which, like the “insane” mode of a Tesla S, was a sleek and dangerous combination.

The Pabst folks did throw me a bone, the promise of “a new beer called Rainier Pale Mountain Ale that you should see hitting the shelves soon!” It’s an American Pale Ale that clocks at 5.3% and early tasters on Beer Advocate give it mixed reviews. But at well over $10 for a six-pack of 12 oz bottles, it’s priced for a completely different market than Rainier Ale; part of the pleasure of the latter was feeling you were getting a good value as well as a buzz, since a 16 oz can was often priced as low as a dollar. (Of course, they were usually sold as singles.)

Rather than closing on a sad note, I will refer you to a fascinating article on about an experiment to brew a collaborative version of Green Death for San Francisco Strong Beer Week in 2013. Turns out Neal Casady (hero of Kerouac’s “On The Road”) was a fan of the original product, as was San Francisco Chronicle columnist Charles McCabe “who used to drink several in the mornings” before going to work. Now that there’s no competition, maybe these guys (Anchor and Speakeasy were mentioned among the collaborators) can be convinced to bring it back.


Posted in Drinking | Tagged , | 2 Comments

A tour of Saratoga mineral springs

My baker friend Tom turned me on to the Cooking Issues podcast of Dave Arnold, who is an artisanal cocktail maker in Brooklyn among many other skills. Arnold recently visited our fair city to sample and make cocktails from the ubiquitous and generally unloved Saratoga mineral springs. His visit prompted me to share how I torment my own out-of-town guests by inviting them to sip a dozen of these memorable waters over a couple of hours. Let’s go.

Geyser Island Spouter

Geyser Island Spouter in Spa Park. By Ryan Hodnett (Own work) [CC BY-SA 4.0], via Wikimedia Commons

We’ll start at the Visitor’s Bureau (Broadway at Congress), where you’ll pick up a guide to the mineral springs. (You can also download it here.) Right across the street is Congress Park, where a number of outlets are clustered. (A spring consists of a pipe that descends into the underground aquifer, and a usually rusty and forbidding fountain where the water comes out.) Here you will find Congress Spring (named, as is the park, for an early settler who was a member of Congress) and Columbian Spring, which is a little joke by the city fathers that simply delivers our not very good tap water.

Before you leave the area, walk north across Spring Street to Hathorn Spring. This is generally considered to be the foulest of the waters, and it’s what Dave Arnold used to make his Saratoga Margarita. It’s so salty and metallic it has to be good for you. (The brochure says it’s “cathartic, diuretic, ‘grateful to the stomach’.” A few cocktails mixed with this stuff will definitely set you up.)

Now, make your way via car or bike to Spa Park for the Geyser Trail loop. The Geyser Island Spouter sits on a mound of tailings in the middle of a creek, and Arnold waded across to get a picture of himself drinking from it. You can stay onshore and sample from several taps, then walk the short (around ¼ mile) trail that takes you behind the SPAC concert pavilion (go during an event and you might catch a famous musician taking a smoke break) and up a slight rise to the Orenda Spring (source of some Martian-looking exudations you’ll pass on your journey) then back the way you came.

State Seal Water

Label for State Seal, Saratoga’s original bottled water

Just a short detour from the Geyser Spring parking lot, on the access road, takes you to the unmarked Polaris Spring. This one is said to be radioactive but I’ve quaffed here many times and never developed a glow. Now, back in your car, drive to State Seal Spring on Avenue of the Pines, opposite the Auto Museum which is the site of the original bottling plant. State Seal is the same product sold in the familiar blue bottles (which are now produced across Highway 50, in an anonymous facility that does not offer tours) and folks bring 5 gallon jugs to get it for free.

While sipping your State Seal (or the salty Geyser Spring water, available from a corroded tap in the same pavilion), you can contemplate the timeless nature of human greed and folly. The pavilion is named for Joe Bruno, a disgraced then partially rehabilitated Capital District politician, and a photo of him on an educational sign has been defaced in various ways. In the 1890s, a Scrooge McDuck-style villain hatched a plot to shut down this and all other local springs by siphoning out the CO2 to bottle and sell. Luckily, he was thwarted by Spencer Trask, a larger-than-life local hero easily the equal of Gyro Gearloose.

Two more springs worth noting are in and near High Rock Park just east of downtown. High Rock Spring is where George Washington allegedly nursed a hangover one foggy morning in 1787, mixing the mineral water with rum. Down the street at Excelsior and High Rock you’ll find the Old Red Spring. This water is said to have powerful properties for treating eczema (perhaps because it’s opposite a Superfund site, the former natural gas processing plant).

There are a few more Saratoga mineral springs left to explore, if you like, but I’ll leave you here because the Old Saratoga Brewing Company is right down the road on Excelsior. Here during tasting room hours you can sample other local beverages (including root beer for the underage) with a different but equally salutary effect. Air do shlàinte!

Posted in Drinking, Something Else | Tagged , , | 8 Comments

How to hack your prime rib dinner

Prime Rib Dinner

My prime rib dinner, day two (except for Yorkshire pudding which needs to be eaten on the spot)

Last night I enjoyed a prime rib dinner at House of Prime Rib in San Francisco. This is a fine specimen of the genre, with long waits for tables and toque’d carvers rolling silver trays hither and yon. The concept is simple. You pay $45-50 which may seem like a lot or quite reasonable depending on your point of reference (a buffet in Las Vegas today is in a similar range; an unadorned steak at Salt and Char in Saratoga will set you back $68) and y0u get a large salad, a mini-loaf of Boudin sourdough bread, the meat with its juice, an enormous baked potato, some creamed spinach, some Yorkshire pudding and a tray of horseradish sauces at varying degrees of intensity.

Here is the key to a successful prime rib dinner. Order the biggest cut (which here costs just a few dollars more than the smallest cut), eat only what you want, and take the rest home along with the accompaniments for a second meal (and maybe third) whe the meat will be as good or better the next day. I always order the end cut (also called the baseball cut) which gives you the maximum amount of crusty caramelized exterior. Sometimes it’s a bit more well done than I like but this time I was lucky and the interior meat was medium rare.

I once worked in a prime rib restaurant and can tell you the formula is very simple. Buy quality beef and age it a bit so the moisture content is reduced. We’d rub with salt and pepper and cook in a convection oven to 140 degrees exterior temperature (so the outside is well done, the center is rare) and that was it. Like any beef, it will taste better when allowed to rest instead of immediately after it is sliced.

You can reheat your prime rib dinner, or eat the meat cold by itself or sliced for sandwiches. You can also cut it into 1-inch cubes and sauté with a little butter, garlic and wine and serve over potatoes. We used to do this with the leftover roasts at the prime rib place where I worked and make a house meal. We used vermouth for the wine because we had it on hand for Destination Shrimp.

By the way, how do I waltz in and eat immediately when others wait 2 hours or so for a table? Because I’m alone and I sit at the bar. I miss the hand carving and artistic salad tossing, but conversation with fellow diners (often quirky solo curmudgeons, like me) makes up for it.

Posted in Eating | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Food for thought: Legends of Texas Barbecue Cookbook

If you are going to get just one book on Texas barbecue, Legends of Texas Barbecue Cookbook is a good choice. Robb Walsh is an active but impartial reviewer of the turbulent smokehouse scene who has commented on this blog from time to time. He describes the basics of how to do it, organizes the content along logical story lines (pork is completely separate from beef, for example, as it should be) and doesn’t shirk from controversy (he explains the origins of the Kreutz/Schmidt family feud in Lockhart, for example).

And recipes! In addition to original guidance for cooking basic dishes, Walsh shares a number of recipes he has picked up in his many days on the Texas barbecue trail. Laura Novostad’s Confetti Slaw, which we modified to produce this version, is one good example. (The current edition has been updated with 32 new recipes… including Aaron Franklin’s Expresso Barbecue Sauce.) Like on Burnt My Fingers, he tries to keep the preparation straightforward so you get a lot of good taste for a reasonable amount of effort. Check it out.

Posted in Food for Thought | Leave a comment

Recipe: Two-Minute Cole Slaw

Two Minute Cole Slaw

Two-Minute Cole Slaw

One minute in express checkout line + one minute mixing ingredients = two-minute cole slaw. And it’s pretty good for the time invested. You do need to let it sit an hour or so before serving, however. Inspired by Laura Novostad’s Confetti Slaw in Robb Walsh’s BBQ cookbook; she told him she came up with the recipe because her Taylor TX diners were no longer content with canned peaches as the only side dish. Serves 4-6.

14-oz package cole slaw mix (OR equivalent amount of shredded green cabbage/red cabbage/carrots)
1/2 c Wishbone or other bottled Italian dressing
A little chopped onion (maybe 2 T for the 14-oz cole slaw package)
Cider or white vinegar to taste
Salt and pepper to taste

Method: Toss the cole slaw mix with the dressing then refrigerate 1 hour before serving. If you have a bit of patience, taste and add salt and vinegar if needed to round it out.

Posted in Recipes, Sides | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Recipe: Buttermilk Cheese Grits

Shies Cheese Grits

Buttermilk Cheese Grits with Shiso

Cheese Grits are the traditional accompaniment to braised short ribs but when they’re made with lots of butter the net effect is just too heavy and fatty. So I cut the fat with buttermilk and added some shiso leaves for contrasting bitterness. Serves 4-6.

1 c polenta or yellow or white corn grits
3 c water (approximate)
1 c buttermilk
2 T butter
½ c or more grated sharp cheddar cheese (variations welcome as long as the cheese has some personality to it)
1 t salt
½ t ground pepper (black or white)
2 T or more shiso, basil, mint or other bitter herb, chiffonade

Method: Bring 2 c water to boil with salt and add polenta. Simmer until it begins to thicken then add butter, cheese and pepper. When cheese is melted add buttermilk. Watch closely and stir frequently as the mixture continues to thicken. Taste after 5 minutes or so to confirm the grits are smooth and flavorful, not at all crunchy. Add more water/buttermilk/cheese/seasoning if you like and continue simmering.

Finished grits should be thick enough to stick to spoon instead of dripping off, but not thicker; they will continue to thicken a bit after you turn off the heat. Just before you serve, mix in the shredded bitter herbs.

Posted in Recipes, Sides | Tagged , | Leave a comment

Recipe: Kentucky Short Ribs

Kentucky Short Ribs

Kentucky Short Ribs with Buttermilk Cheese Grits and a side of milkweed*

Why Kentucky Short Ribs? Because instead of a regular flour dredge, I used the leftover 11 herbs and spices mix from the KFC Chicken recipe. Otherwise, this is a classic prep that will bring out the best in these succulent body parts. Allow 1 large rib per person (3/4 lb).

Ingredients to serve 4:
3 lbs short ribs
½ c KFC mix for dredging OR ½ c all purpose flour mixed with 1 t salt and ½ t black pepper
1 large onion, peeled and chopped
3 cloves garlic, peeled and chopped
4 medium carrots, peeled and sliced
2 T butter
2 T olive oil
1 c red wine
3 bay leaves
Few sprigs fresh thyme (optional)
½ lb mushrooms, cleaned and sliced

Method: heat oil and 1 T butter in a dutch oven; sauté onions and garlic until soft then add carrots and cook for a few minutes. Reserve the vegetables in a bowl. Dredge the short ribs in flour mixture and brown the ribs, turning until all sides are nice and crisp. Do this in batches if necessary. Pour off excess oil, then return the vegetables to the pot and add wine, bay leaves and optional thyme. Cover and cook 1 ½ hours over low heat or until meat has started to pull away from the bone and is very tender; add water as needed to make sure you have a good amount of liquid at the end.

Meanwhile, sauté mushrooms in 1 T butter. Add to the short ribs about 15 minutes before servings so the flavors can merge. Serve over polenta, grits or other starch to soak up the delicious gravy.

*Yep, the milkweed’s back. A late season second crop came up in my yard so I grabbed a bunch of the young tender shoots and sautéed them up like this.

Posted in Mains, Recipes | Tagged | Leave a comment

Five most popular non-recipe posts on Burnt My Fingers

We have a few big shifts in these guys as we celebrate our fifth anniversary.

  1. What’s the best flour for baking bread? Yes, that’s a good question and we answer it along with an explanation.

  2. The sauce that made Mr. Durkee famous. The current owner of the brand is not interested in its history but our readers certainly are.

  3. Why I’m not buying a Sansaire sous vide device. The alternative device I recommended has long since been discontinued, but folks keep coming back for discussion. Be sure to read the comments.

  4. Turkey Joints from Nora’s of Rome, NY. A secondary mission is to explore the quirky food traditions of upstate New York, where your correspondent spends most of his time. I made a detour on a bitter cold day and got some, but not all, of the story of this esoteric candy.

  5. Stuff to Buy. This page provides Amazon links to some hard to find or especially handy kitchen items which we use on a regular basis. We get a small commission if you end up ordering them, which helps pay for the pixels.

Also, these didn’t make the top five but get honorable mention for orneriness of the commenters. Check out Can Barbecue Be Racist? (I knew that title would be like squirting lighter fluid on a raging fire) and A Long Strange Trip to the Perfect Pickle.

Posted in Something Else | Leave a comment